Showing posts with label Distributors as customers. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Distributors as customers. Show all posts

Friday, 20 March 2015

Distributor Etiquette Hate Mail


It’s not often that I get real, honest to goodness “hate mail”.  Apparently, our thoughts on Distributor/Supplier Etiquette
have touched a nerve.  The strange part of the whole thing is this:  We are only posting on distributor/channel oriented groups.  These groups are focused on those who are either a) distributors or b) manufacturers who go to market through distribution.  They should be friends or at least tolerant of one another.
Yet in the past week, I have received emails and/or anonymous posts which contain things like this:

“Frank, you are a distributor apologist.  You claim to be open minded but your writing continues to indicate they can do no wrong.”

Taking excerpts from several other notes, we find a similar type of attitude.  Distributors are described as follows:
The remnants of a day gone by with no place in the modern age.

Lazy, to the point of not being willing to introduce new products or handle warranty claims…

Unwilling to carry inventory except on their biggest lines…

Slowly dropping their commitment to training new people…
Completely different to deal with then in my younger days…

Going even further, here is the entirety of one of the best (worst) posts on the state of distribution:
“The problem is that MOST distributors today are going through the same LEAN supply chain consolidation as most industry. Other than their fast moving mfg, they are extremely and increasingly risk averse to carrying inventory. This creates a ton of pressure on the supply chain. In my opinion, most distributors create little value, even though they talk about it quite a bit. They add margin, drop ship a good lot, and do less and less of what they are supposed to do which is to have products in stock.”

For the record, I believe distributors are neither partners nor customers.  They are often an extremely efficient and effective “instrument” for getting product to market.   Many suppliers would struggle if they were suddenly charged with carrying the massive accounts receivables load for all of their customers.  A good many suppliers would struggle to get customer attention if their product was not packaged with the product of another manufacturer to create a solution. 
In the current model, power house supplier get preferential treatment.  Most of them command greater respect with their distributors.  Perhaps this person is upset because they are not a high power supplier. 


By the way, I love hate mail almost as much as I like emails of praise.  Drop me a line if you think I am getting prematurely senile.  

Friday, 13 March 2015

More on Distributor Supplier Etiquette: The Supply Partner Side


Distributors: customers, partners or something in between?
The Supply-Partner side of the Etiquette Story

The whole etiquette issue is not one sided. Over the last couple of weeks we have received several calls and comments on the topic: What part of distributor/supplier etiquette bugs you the most?

This week I would like to hit on a point made by a couple of folks on the supplier side. To launch the topic, here is a comment many great supply-partners feel throws a wet blanket on the partnering equation.

“Don’t forget, we (Distributors) are the customer.”

As I think back in time, I realize I might have used this line a few times myself. Reflecting on the subject, I see both sides of the argument. Speaking for distributors, I can see some validity in the point. We write checks to the supplier; often paying with much greater rapidity and regularity than those who finally end up with the product. I struggle to recall a manufacturer who extends anything other than 30 day terms. Yet, most Fortune 500 companies have unilaterally declared their own buying terms of at least 60 days. How can they do that? Because, they really are the customer.






Distributors may be the customer in other ways. After they buy the product they are often stuck with a plethora of widgets that don’t exactly fly off the shelf. Increasingly, distributors are bundling services and products, building sub-assemblies and, in many industry segments, creating turnkey solutions for those who later buy the product from them. This, too, sounds a lot like a customer.

However, the argument breaks down from there. If distributors are customers, they are a special type. Typically, there is a contract defining the scope of the relationship which doesn’t exist with “garden variety” customers. The supply-partner can walk away from other customers, without legal implications. Distributors operating in many states are protected from no fault termination by 1950s franchise protection laws. Further, distributors are given special pricing, marketing support and often, intellectual property not shared with common customers.

Somewhere along the way, distributors associated as customers, become something more. When things work well, and for most distributors and their major supply-partners it does, the relationship looks more like (and I hate to use an over worked term) a partnership. At times, even the best partnerships are strained and the distributor/supply-partner rapport is often put under stress.

A few years ago Michael Marks co-wrote a book called, Working at Cross Purposes: How Distributors and Manufacturers can Manage Conflict Successfully. The work describes the differences in the business models of distributors and their Supply-Partner manufacturers. The business models generally mesh well, but human nature tends to cause us to dwell on the conflict part.

This brings me to my last point. Distribution is a business model not a way of life. For some of us who are second or even third generation wholesale distributors, one point must be revisited often. The most successful business models change with conditions. Distribution today doesn’t look much like it did when my dad launched his distributorship in the early 1960s. Companies filling the ranks of his line of trade have evolved to the point at which they hardly resemble life at Hurtte Oil Company.

What does all of this mean? Well, the day we become merely customers instead of distributors is a day we may be skating out onto some mighty precarious ice. Distributors will exist only as long as we can provide services to the customer more economically, more efficiently and better than the supplier can using a direct model.

Are we customers?
I don’t believe so. We are a highly efficient, cost effective, low maintenance channel to market. And as long as we keep our competitive edge by being more nimble than manufacturer’s organization, we are special.

Distributors demand respect. Savvy manufacturers know that when distributors change brands their customers follow along. The last research paper on the topic points to something like 78 percent of the customers moving to the distributor’s new partner over a three year period.

With this in mind, perhaps the statement might be: Distributors aren’t customers, but the real customers “belong to” the distributor.

What do you think?